Blog / Holiday Sales Strategy 101-How to Turn One Customer Into Five

Holiday Sales Strategy 101-How to Turn One Customer Into Five

Dec 5, 2025

Holiday sales bring new eyes to your business, but repeat customers are where the real profit hides. Here’s how to turn that one-time buyer into a loyal fan.

Build a Repeat Loop

  • Thank-You Inserts-add a card with care instructions, your logo, and a small discount for their next order.
  • Loyalty Freebies-include a mini transfer or sticker sample in every holiday shipment.
  • Customer Spotlight Posts -feature customer creations on your page to encourage UGC.

Automate the Connection

  • Set up an email follow-up 10 days post-delivery with a thank-you and reorder link.
  • Use QR codes on packaging to direct buyers to your site or Pinterest projects.
  • Offer a referral code your customers can share with friends for a bonus.

Download our Repeat Customer Tracker, a spreadsheet to log purchases, follow-ups, and engagement for your top buyers.

👉 Free Download